Interview spotlight: Rosalind L Smyth, Director and Professor of Child Health UCL Great Ormond St Institute of Child Health
We are delighted to interview Professor Rosalind L Smyth MAE about her work as a clinician and academic at the UCL Great Ormond St Institute of Child Health, her commitment to Open Access and her views on gender equality in science.
About Rosalind L Smyth
Rosalind L Smyth MAE is Director at Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health & Professor of Child Health at UCL. In 2015, she was appointed Commander of the Order of the British Empire (CBE) for services to the regulation of medicines for children. She was elected to the Academia Europaea in 2018.
The interview
You are both a clinician and an academic. You have previously said that research would have to be a component in whatever you do. Could you tell us about the benefits and challenges of undertaking both roles?
“The reason I decided, at a young age, to pursue a medical career was because I wanted to make a tangible difference to people’s lives. I also realised, before I went to medical school, that I wanted to be a paediatrician. This was partly because I enjoy working with children and young people, but also because, by intervening early, with prevention or treatments, there is a much greater chance of making a difference to the quality and, indeed the length, of someone’s life. Clinical training is long and can be challenging, but it is an enormous privilege to work with children and help them recover from acute problems and manage more long-term chronic conditions.
My pathway into research was more serendipitous. I was married to another hospital doctor and managing two such careers meant, at that time, we were likely to have to move around the UK. I felt I needed to make sure my CV was as strong as possible and, when we moved to Cambridge, I should look to spend some time as a research fellow to add something extra to my resumé. Like many young women I lacked confidence. At that point, my one goal was someday to become a paediatric consultant. My time in research at Cambridge completely changed my perspectives. I was working in heart-lung transplantation and, in the patient group with which I worked, there were so many questions related to opportunistic infections, physiology and host defence and much more, which needed to be answered. I learnt how to formulate the right questions and how to begin to develop the methods to answer them. I was working in a very successful, dynamic group, where everyone wanted to become a professor (except me), but I slowly became more confident and then more ambitious.
At the end of my research post, my medical husband was appointed to a consultant post in Liverpool and we moved to that city for the next 23 years. I could no longer pursue heart-lung transplantation, but I used some of my ideas and training to consider viral/host defence in condition which had a very high incidence in babies in Liverpool, respiratory syncytial virus bronchiolitis. I was appointed, first of all as a respiratory paediatrician at Alder Hey, the large children’s hospital in Liverpool, but after two years in this role, moved into a clinical senior lectureship at the University of Liverpool and Alder Hey, to pursue a clinical academic career. The challenges of being a competent, committed clinician and an excellent researcher are considerable, but, for me, it is the best job in the world! In terms of challenges, the balance between time spent looking after patients and time devoted to research is an obvious problem all clinical academics face. Patients have to take priority, so one needs a clear structure to ensure that, one’s research time is “ring-fenced” so that other members of the clinical team are able provide appropriate care when the academic is not available.
The quality of the team approach is critical; one absolutely has to fulfil the agreed clinical commitments, but the full-time clinicians should recognise the important academic requirements of their clinical academic colleagues. Clinical academia provides the opportunity for one to have unique insights into the clinical problems and develop the means whereby to answer these questions.
There are many ways in which we can improve patient care, but most of them require careful investigation into the aetiology of health and disease and rigorous clinical studies. In my field, the results make a very real difference to the lives of children, the adults they will become and their families. That is what has always motivated me.”
Could you tell us more about your latest research?
“My current research continues to address RSV bronchiolitis. When I was in Liverpool, we made important observations about neutrophils, which are recruited to the airways during RSV infection. Studies in these small very sick babies are difficult and so, to investigate the role of neutrophils and whether and how they are contributing to recovery from infection, has required the development of new model systems. We have been able to grow airway epithelial cells taken from healthy volunteers, at an air liquid interface, where they differentiate into cells seen in the airway. We have been able to add neutrophils to the basolateral membrane of the epithelial cells, so that they migrate through to the apical membrane, which lines the airway, in life. By using this system, we are able to study the effects of neutrophil migration and RSV infection on the airway epithelium and on the neutrophils, which has improved our understanding of how these cells respond in the clinical condition.
However, most of my time is spent as Director of the UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health. My colleagues work across a very broad range of research questions relevant to child health, including developing treatments for a number of rare childhood diseases where there are no specific treatments and understanding how the circumstances into which a child is born can affect their chances of developing disease and living a long and healthy life. I have incredibly talented and committed colleagues and every day I am reminded about how important their work is to children across the world.”
You have a strong commitment to Open Access and UCL Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health was the first to launch an institute-focused publishing platform with F1000. Why is this so important to you? What are your thoughts about Plan S?
“I have long felt that the old-fashioned model of publishing model was unsustainable in the age of the internet. As a scientist, one makes available for publication the reports of scientific investigation, which is usually publicly funded. One (usually freely) provides quality assurance of these processes by peer review and then one is invited to buy back the product of the endeavour by subscriptions to scientific journals. This impedes scientific progress, as information is not readily available and studies may be duplicated or not developed as a consequence. However it is not only the scientists who are missing out. The public, whose taxes and donations have paid for publicly funded research will not have access to the results of these studies. In my area of research patients and families will also be denied the opportunity of reading studies which may be relevant to them. There is the issue that some research findings may be misleading or flawed and this might cause harm, particularly if, for example, patients are misled about the effects of treatment. However, some publishers, such as F1000 are publishing all of the reviews of the work, with the reviewers identified and the author’s rebuttal(s). This transparency helps to ensure that limitations in the work are identified and the findings can be interpreted more appropriately.
I was a member of the Board of Directors of the Public Library of Science (PLOS) for 10 years. During that time, PLOS was at the vanguard of open access publishing. Since leaving PLOS I have continued to pursue these interests.
I’m generally very supportive of the principles of Plan S. I know that some have found them to be radical and the implementation is over a short time. However, I think that the academic and publishing community has had a chance to consider these matters for a long time and now is the time to act.”
You are passionate about gender equality in science and you actively encourage young women to put themselves forward for senior positions. What positive steps do you think have been made in this area?
“Things are a lot better, but diversity in academic leadership still has a long way to go. Earlier I referred to lack of confidence among young women, early in their research and academic careers. There are very many talented individuals, who don’t believe that they can “make it” with an academic career. While role models are important, practical issues may also be a deterrent. For example, many people are trying to make the transition to independence, with all of the requirements to publish well and obtain grant income, when they are in their 30s and starting a family, with all of the joys and stresses which that provides. Often all that is needed is a facilitatory environment, the right sort of encouragement and, of course, a supportive family.
There is very good evidence that when women apply for fellowships, are nominated for Academy Fellowships, etc., they are at least as successful as men, the problem is that they don’t apply.
So, I have been involved in many initiatives to encourage and support women to apply for these positions and these have led to notable successes. For example, there are now many more female Fellows of the Academy of Medical Sciences than was the case 5-10 years ago.”
20th May 2019. For further information please contact AECardiffHub@cardiff.ac.uk
Interview Spotlight Series
Explore our collection of interviews, featuring Members of Academia Europaea and colleagues connected with the Academy, as they offer insights into critical research topics.
Exploring the bilingual brain: An interview with Professor Li Wei MAE
Published 17th April 2024. Li Wei discusses his groundbreaking research on bilingual brain development, and the significant benefits of language exposure in both childhood and later life.
Bridging science and policy in Europe: Insights from Pearl Dykstra MAE
Published 8th April 2024. Pearl Dykstra discusses her roles within the European Scientific Advice Mechanism, and the importance of collaboration in science and policy.
From the Silk Road to the One Belt, One Road Initiative: an interview with Samuel Lieu
Published 12th March 2024. Samuel Lieu MAE discusses his co-director role in the UNESCO-sponsored ‘Corpus Fontium Manichaeorum’ project, and how his diverse range of scholarly interests led him from the Silk Road to the Byzantine.
AI’s opportunities and challenges: Insights from 2024 Hypatia Prize Winner, Nuria Oliver
Published 23rd February 2024. In this interview, the 2024 winner of the Hypatia European Science Prize, Nuria Oliver MAE, shares her reaction to receiving the award and discusses the opportunities and challenges of Artificial Intelligence.
Building Bridges 2023 Spotlight Series: an interview with Katalin Solymosi
Published 26th October 2023. Katalin Solymosi FYAE, Chair of the Young Academy of Europe, talks about her motivation for taking on the role and her plans for the YAE.
Overcoming barriers in male-dominated world: an interview with Ann-Christine Davis MAE
Published 17th October 2023. Ann-Christine Davis MAE talks about making history as the first female Mathematics professor at Cambridge, the challenges she’s faced, and the positive effect of support from male colleagues.
Building Bridges 2023 Spotlight Series: an interview with Eugene Yeo
Published 10th October 2023. Eugene Yeo, inaugural recipient of the Academia Europaea Sydney Brenner Medal, speaks about his personal connection with Sydney Brenner and continuing his legacy as a mentor.
Building Bridges 2023 Spotlight Series: an interview with Michael Udvardi
Published 10th October 2023. Michael Udvardi, recipient of the The Adam Kondorosi Academia Europaea Award for Advanced Research 2023, shares why this award is special to him and his research into sustainable agriculture.
Building Bridges 2023 Spotlight Series: an interview with Jean-Pierre Changeux
Published 10th October 2023. Jean Pierre Changeux MAE, Academia Europaea’s Erasmus medal winner, shares what the award means to him and discusses key aspects of his research.
Building Bridges 2023 Spotlight Series: an interview with Johanna Ivaska MAE
Published 9th October 2023. Johanna Ivaska MAE shares her passion for cancer research and the challenges faced by female scientists.
A conversation on gender equity and allyship in STEM: an interview with Jeremy Sanders MAE
Published 11th September 2023. Jeremy Sanders MAE talks about his personal inclusion agenda and setting an example as a male ally.
AE’s Annual Conference in Munich: An invitation from Don Dingwell
Published 4th September 2023. Don Dingwell MAE, Vice-President of Academia Europaea, extends a warm welcome to all Members for our 2023 Annual Conference.
Why we need more women in science: An interview with Dame Athene Donald MAE
Published 27th June 2023. Dame Athene Donald MAE talks about her book which examines the modern way of working in scientific research and how gender bias operates within it, drawing on the experiences of leading women in science.
30 years of the European Review: an interview with Alban Kellerbauer
Published 1st June 2023. European Review Editor-in-Chief, Alban Kellerbauer MAE, discusses his ambitions for the journal, and what makes the ER distinctive.
Telling the stories of women scientists: An interview with Magdolna Hargittai MAE
Published 12th May 2023. Magdolna Hargittai MAE discusses her book which focuses on the achievements of female scientists and the importance of role models in promoting and supporting more women in STEM.
Telling the story of émigré scientists: An interview with Istvan Hargittai MAE
Published 3rd May 2023. Istvan Hargittai MAE discusses his motivation for writing his latest book Brilliance in Exile, which explores the lives of Hungarian émigré scientists who have made significant contributions to science after leaving their country of birth.
Interview with Jaume Bertranpetit MAE, AE Barcelona Knowledge Hub Academic Director
Published 20th March 2023. Jaume Bertranpetit MAE, Barcelona Knowledge Hub’s Academic Director tells us about his priorities and ambitions for the Hub.
Changing landscapes in academia: an interview with Susan Wray MAE
Published 7th March 2023. Marking International Women’s Day 2023, Susan Wray MAE shares her passion for physiology, and the people who have had the greatest impact on her work and career. She discusses gender equality in academia as well as her hopes for the next generation of scientists.
An interview with Katalin Solymosi and Linn Leppert
Published 19th December 2022. Katalin Solymosi FYAE and Linn Leppert FYAE discuss Equality, Diversity and Inclusion, their experiences as women in science and the importance of the CALIPER project in addressing the gender balance in STEM fields.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Carl-Henrik Heldin MAE
Published 27th October 2022. Carl-Henrik Heldin MAE shares his views on the role of science in addressing global challenges, and his work with the Nobel Foundation.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Sierd Cloetingh MAE
Published 27th October 2022. Sierd Cloetingh MAE, recipient of the Academia Europaea’s 2022 Gold Award, gives us his reaction to receiving the award and tells us about some of his activities on behalf of AE.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Philippe Aghion MAE
Published 27th October 2022. Philippe Aghion MAE, Erasmus medal winner, tells us about his work on growth and innovation.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Nancy Cartwright MAE
Published 27th October 2022. Nancy Cartwright MAE, winner of the Hypatia Prize, tells us about her recent work and the role philosophy can play in facing present-day challenges.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Sir Shankar Balasubramanian and Helga Nowotny MAE
Published 26th October 2022. In this joint interview, Sir Shankar Balasubramanian and Helga Nowotny MAE discuss a range of topics, including innovation, interdisciplinary research, public and policy engagement, and the impacts of technology.
Building Bridges 2022 Spotlight Series: an interview with Moniek Tromp FYAE
Published 26th October 2022. Moniek Tromp FYAE, Chair of the Young Academy of Europe, tells us about her ambitions and priorities for the YAE.
Celebrating physiology: an interview with David Paterson MAE
Published 4th October 2022. David Paterson MAE, President of the Physiological Society, was in Cardiff on 29th September 2022 to mark the life and work of neurophysiologist Thomas Graham Brown FRS (1882-1965).
Mathematics and Planet Earth: an interview with Valerio Lucarini MAE
Published 1st September 2022. Valerio Lucarini MAE explains the role of mathematics in climate science, the importance of interdisciplinary research collaboration and the need to engage with policymakers.
Music as a strategic issue of Ukrainian independence: an interview with Lyubov Kyyanovska MAE
Published 17th August 2022. Luba Kyyanovska MAE discusses her life as a musicologist, from her early studies in L’viv to life beyond the fall of the Iron Curtain.
Life as a Ukrainian scientist: an interview with Yaroslav Shuba MAE
Published 21st July 2022. Yaroslav Shuba MAE charts his life as a scientist, from the Soviet era to independent Ukraine.
Dedicating my next 20 years to climate change: An interview with Sir David King FRS MAE
Published 14th March 2022. AAAS Award winner and former UK Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir David King MAE, shares his ambitious plans to tackle the global challenge of climate change.
The rewards and challenges of working in mental health: an interview with Professor Karina Lovell
Published 24th January 2022. Karina Lovell MAE shares insights into her career and research in the mental health sector.
My passion to serve the research community: an interview with Academia Europaea’s new President, Professor Marja Makarow
Published 13th January 2022. In her first interview as President of Academia Europaea, Marja Makarow MAE tells us about her leadership roles and sets out some of her priorities for Academia Europaea.
A life in science with Professor Ole Petersen
Published 8th November 2021. Ole Petersen MAE, winner of Academia Europaea’s Gold Medal 2021 and the Cardiff Knowledge Hub’s Academic Director, speaks to us about the honour of receiving the Gold Medal and the current challenges he sees for science.
Special interview with Sir Roger Penrose, Nobel laureate and winner of Academia Europaea’s Erasmus Medal
Published26th October 2021. This interview with world-renowned mathematician, physicist and Nobel laureate, Sir Roger Penrose MAE, took place following a very special award ceremony in Oxford, on 24th September, at which Sir Roger was presented with the 2021 Erasmus Medal.
Looking through the lens of good science, by Professor David Allison MAE
Published 15th September 2021. David Allison MAE, expert in nutrition and obesity, tells us about his passion for scientific rigour and evidence-informed policymaking.
A special collective spirit: Reflections on my time as President of Academia Europaea by Professor Sierd Cloetingh
Published 28th June 2021. Marking AE Cardiff’s 5th anniversary, Sierd Cloetingh MAE shares highlights from his role as President of Academia Europaea and reflects on the impact of the Academy’s work.
The role of the Young Academy of Europe by Dr Gemma Modinos, FYAE
Published 26th November 2020. Gemma Modinos FYAE, Chair of the Young Academy of Europe, talks about her vision and priorities for the YAE.
From Research to Public Health Policy by Professor Martin McKee MAE
Published 12th May 2020. Martin McKee MAE tells us about his passion for Public Health, his role at the European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies and his research on the adverse effects of movement restrictions in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Understanding asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease by Professor Peter Barnes MAE
Published 27th April 2020. Peter Barnes tells us about his career highlights and the effect of COVID-19 on his research.
Making decisions at times of uncertainty, by Nils-Eric Sahlin MAE
Published 20th April 2020.Nils-Eric Sahlin MAE tells us about his research on decision-making under conditions of uncertainty, and his contribution to the evidence review on Making Sense of Science for Policy, coordinated by Academia Europaea.
Examining the sustainability of our food systems: By Peter Jackson MAE
Published 9th April 2020. Peter Jackson MAE tells us why he became involved in the study of food, and his role in the publication of a major evidence review on sustainable food systems.
Working at the interface between academia and policy, by Barbara Prainsack MAE
Published 26th February 2020. Barbara Prainsack MAE shares her experiences of the vital relationship between academia and policy.
My research career in big data analysis by Yike Guo, Imperial College London
Published 20th January 2020. Yike Guo MAE discusses the importance of big data analysis, the impact of his international education and his continued links with China.
Priorities for Plan S by Open Access Champion Johan Rooryck
Published 23rd September 2019. Open Access Champion, Johan Rooryck MAE, shares his priorities for Plan S and his passion for Open Access publishing.
Progress at the Academia Europaea’s Tbilisi Hub, Georgia, by David Prangishvili
Published 13th September 2019. The Academia Europaea’s 5th Knowledge Hub launched in Tbilisi, Georgia, in April 2019. In this interview, David Prangishvili MAE, Tbilisi Knowledge Hub’s Academic Director, tells us about his priorities for the Hub.
Interview spotlight: Dr Mangala Srinivas, Chair of the Young Academy of Europe (YAE)
Published 1st August 2019. Mangala Srinivas FYAE, Chair of the Young Academy of Europe (YAE), discusses the impact of being awarded an ERC Starting Grant, her role as the Chair of the Young Academy of Europe and why the YAE became involved in the debate on Plan S.
Interview spotlight: Professor Peter Hegyi, Director of the Centre of Translational Medicine, the University of Pécs
Published 1st July 2019. Peter Hegyi MAE, provides an insight into the importance of Translational Medicine.
Interview Spotlight: Theo D’haen, Emeritus Professor of English and Comparative Literature, KU Leuven
Published 18th June 2019. Theo D’haen MAE, Professor Emeritus at KU Leuven talks about his career highlights, the relevance of his research, the role of international collaboration in research and his thoughts on Plan S.
Interview spotlight: Rosalind L Smyth, Director and Professor of Child Health UCL Great Ormond St Institute of Child Health
Published 20th May 2019. Rosalind L Smyth MAE talks about her work as a clinician and academic at the UCL Great Ormond St Institute of Child Health, her commitment to Open Access and her views on gender equality in science.
Interview Spotlight: Christopher Smith, Professor of Ancient History, University of St Andrews
Published 20th November 2018. Christopher Smith MAE shares his most noteworthy professional experiences, explains how his research relates to modern society and tells us more about Sovereignty: a global perspective held in April 2019.
Interview Spotlight: John Tucker, Professor of Computer Science, Swansea University
Published 2nd August 2018. John Tucker MAE shares his professional highlights and what being a Member of Academia Europaea means to him.
Interview Spotlight: Lord Martin Rees, Astronomer Royal
Published 6th March 2018. Astronomer Royal Martin Rees, The Lord Rees of Ludlow, talks about how to successfully engage the public with science and gives us an insight into his book On the Future: Prospects for Humanity.
Interview spotlight: Professor Ole Petersen, Cardiff Hub Academic Director and Vice-President Academia Europaea
Published 4th January 2017. As the very first in our Interview spotlight series, Ole Petersen MAE shares highlights of his life and career.